The Missing Hour: ECI Records Go Blank After 5 PM in 200 Constituencies

The Missing Hour: ECI Records Go Blank After 5 PM in 200 Constituencies

A major investigative report by The Reporters’ Collective exposed gaps in the ECI records of 2024 elections, raising fresh questions

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026: New Delhi: The ECI is facing renewed scrutiny after an investigation published on November 18 revealed that its internal records contain no figures for votes polled between 5 pm and 6 pm in 200 parliamentary and Assembly constituencies across Maharashtra, Haryana and Jammu and Kashmir.

The findings are particularly disturbing because polling procedures require officials to record EVM vote totals at two-hour intervals until the conclusion of voting. These figures are supposed to be checked against the independently maintained voter records.

The Reporters’ Collective examined 4,212 physical records relating to 467 Assembly and 63 Lok Sabha constituencies that went to the polls in 2024. Its investigation found that the final-hour figures were missing in 200 constituencies.

Maharashtra accounted for the largest share, with 132 constituencies affected, followed by Jammu & Kashmir with 45 and Haryana with 23.

The final hour of polling is particularly important. Election observers and experts have warned that polling stations can become more vulnerable to irregularities when party agents leave, particularly where political parties are struggling to maintain their presence.

Without the required records, the ECI’s ability to reconstruct and independently scrutinise what happened during that period is compromised.

The Eknath Shinde constituency raises another question

One of the most striking examples highlighted by the investigation concerns Kopri-Pachpakhadi in Thane, Maharashtra, the constituency represented by Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde.

The investigation says its records showed approximately 1.13 lakh votes polled by 5 pm, while the final figure was reported at approximately 2.03 lakh. It calculated that nearly 90,000 votes were cast during the remaining period across 366 polling booths. That would represent an extraordinary voting rate if the figures and time period are accurate.

However, the precise final tally and calculation need reconciliation with the official constituency result before being published as an established fact. The central finding about missing post-5 pm records is separate from this particular calculation.

A second investigation deepens the controversy

This is Part Two of The Reporters’ Collective’s Election Audit series of the ECI

Its first investigation found discrepancies between votes recorded as cast and votes counted in 51 constituencies across the three regions.

The latest investigation raises another concern: in 23 constituencies, officials also failed to maintain records of the queue slips issued to voters waiting when polling officially closed.

These slips matter because voters already standing in queues at closing time are permitted to vote after the deadline. The slips help establish who was entitled to remain and cast a ballot. The investigation says the absence of these records makes subsequent scrutiny considerably more difficult.

What has the ECI said?

The Reporters’ Collective says it sent detailed questions to the ECI and the respective state electoral authorities. According to the investigation, its questions were routed through the public grievance system, and the Commission asked the journalists to provide the Commission with its own records.

The ECI’s published procedures also provide for Form 17C, the account of votes recorded, to be given to polling agents at the close of polling.

The question India deserves answered

Elections are the foundation of representative democracy. The Election Commission is not simply an administrative department conducting a national exercise. It is a constitutional institution entrusted with protecting the credibility of the people’s mandate. If records required for monitoring polling are missing across 200 constituencies, citizens deserve a clear explanation.

Were the records never prepared? Were they prepared but not transmitted? Were they lost? Were the omissions investigated? And what independent verification can establish that the final-hour voting was conducted entirely according to procedure?

These are questions that cannot be dismissed as political allegations.

JANPATH NEWS NETWORK (JNN)
Independent. Fearless. On the People’s Path.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *