CJI Surya Kant’s move highlights questions over judicial powers, case allocation and the handling of religiously sensitive issues
Thursday November 19, New Delhi: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has withdrawn two cases from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, reportedly averting a potential religious controversy over judicial directions concerning stray animals and the limits of a Supreme Court bench’s authority.
According to a Times of India report published on November 19, the decision was taken after concerns emerged that the bench had expanded individual cases involving administrative lapses into nationwide judicial exercises against similar alleged irregularities.
One of the most contentious orders was passed on August 4, when the bench directed all states and Union Territories to remove stray animals from public places. The directive triggered concerns because a substantial proportion of stray cattle are cows and calves, animals that carry deep religious significance for many Hindus.
A resident of Uttar Pradesh subsequently approached the court, warning that the blanket direction could lead to cows and their offspring being rounded up, transported or disposed of without adequate regard for their constitutional protection and animal welfare.
The applicant argued that cows have traditionally been revered as gaumata and cautioned that indiscriminate implementation could hurt religious sentiments. He also raised the possibility of stray cattle being transported across state borders, confined in inadequate facilities or subjected to conditions that violate the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960.
However, the controversy surrounding the order was not limited to its religious implications. The report states that the CJI’s decision, backed by the four senior-most Supreme Court judges, followed concerns that a bench not assigned the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) roster could not create PIL jurisdiction for itself by converting individual disputes into nationwide judicial proceedings.
Background to This Ruling:
Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah was hearing cases concerning stray animals. Instead of dealing only with the specific complaints before him, his bench expanded the matter into a nationwide exercise, directing all states and Union Territories to remove stray animals from public places. The order raised a religious controversy. Since many stray animals are cows, concerns were raised that the order could lead to cows and calves being rounded up, transported or placed in unsuitable facilities, potentially hurting religious sentiments and violating animal welfare laws.
The CJI intervened over the judge’s authority and reportedly felt that the bench had gone beyond its assigned jurisdiction. He reassigned the cases, and took the two cases away from Justice Amanullah’s bench.
The allocation of cases and determination of the court’s roster fall within the Chief Justice’s administrative authority.
The development therefore brings two sensitive questions into focus: how far individual Supreme Court benches can expand the scope of cases before them, and how judicial directions affecting religiously sensitive subjects should be framed and implemented.
The CJI’s intervention underscores the importance of judicial discipline, proper case allocation and institutional checks within the country’s highest court.
JANPATH NEWS NETWORK (JNN)
Independent. Fearless. On the People’s Path.













